Alerte Phonegate — iPhone 12 dossier — European Commission
We are seeking the documentation for the algorithms and sensors that can change a phone’s transmission power during specific absorption rate (SAR) compliance testing.
How do these mechanisms work? Under what conditions are they activated? How can we ensure independent, reproducible tests?
Why we are taking the case to the EU courts
Since 11 February 2026, Alerte Phonegate has been fighting to obtain the technical documents needed to understand and verify how power-management algorithms, proximity and motion sensors, and Time-Averaging SAR (TAS) affect SAR testing.
Despite the Commission’s responses of 27 April and 10 August 2026, some material remains redacted or withheld, notably on the grounds of commercial interests. On 19 October 2026, our NGO is filing an action before the General Court of the European Union to challenge these restrictions on access.
Help fund this legal battle
This work is carried out by volunteers and requires legal and technical resources. Your support helps us pursue this action and make the documents accessible to everyone.
Documents available to everyone
The Commission identified 68 document files and their annexes. Below are 35 links to PDFs already made public on its portal, grouped by organisation. Some versions have been partially redacted.
ANFR: inspections and correspondence (13)
- ANFR non-compliance report: limb SAR of 5.615 W/kgDOCUMENT 8 — Full access
Administrative non-compliance report: shortcomings in information on exposure and power levels, and a limb SAR of 5.615 W/kg at 0 mm, exceeding the 4 W/kg limit. The inspection date was 16 November 2021; this must not be confused with the test date.
- 11 October 2022 — ANFR informs Apple of non-complianceDOCUMENT 3 — Partial access
ANFR informs Apple of non-compliance found after a sample was obtained at the FNAC store in Nancy. It opens an adversarial procedure and warns of possible formal notice, followed by withdrawal or recall if Apple’s observations do not change its findings.
- 21 December 2022 — Formal notice to AppleDOCUMENT 7 — Partial access
Formal notice of 21 December 2022: ANFR considers Apple’s observations insufficient and requires compliance or withdrawal/recall within six weeks. Much of the intervening reasoning is redacted.
- 26 April 2023 — Algorithm documentation and continuing non-complianceDOCUMENT 13 — Partial access
ANFR reiterates that information about the algorithm should have been included in the technical documentation so that testing could be conducted without the manufacturer’s assistance. It finds that the non-compliance persists and allows one month for corrective measures.
- 11 September 2023 — Provisional withdrawal and recall decisionDOCUMENT 17 — Partial access
ANFR decision of 11 September 2023 ordering the provisional withdrawal and recall of the iPhone 12 A2403. It describes the procedure, health and safety requirements and continuing exceedances. Several passages explaining the decision are redacted.
- 12 September 2023 — Notice to Apple and possible sanctionsDOCUMENT 16 — Partial access
Notification of provisional withdrawal and recall following continuing non-compliance despite the test protocol provided by Apple. ANFR also considers an administrative penalty and announces that it will inform the Commission and other Member States.
- 21 December 2022 — Formal notice to FNACDOCUMENT 24 — Partial access
Formal notice to FNAC dated 21 December 2022, requiring it to remove the devices from the market within four weeks. ANFR reiterates the distributor’s responsibilities and possible sanctions.
- 11 October 2022 — ANFR letter to notified body ULDOCUMENT 25 — Partial access
ANFR informs notified body UL of the non-compliance detected in the iPhone 12 and the proceedings involving the economic operator. The letter links the findings to conformity-assessment obligations.
- 5 January 2024 — ANFR letter forwarded to the CommissionDOCUMENT 40.1 — Partial access
Email of 5 January 2024 forwarding ANFR’s letter to the Commission, together with an annex reproducing Apple’s public statement on SAR testing.
- 5 January 2024 — ANFR challenges the Irish objectionDOCUMENT 40.3 — Partial access
ANFR challenges the admissibility of the Irish objection, in particular because ComReg did not carry out independent measurements. It reiterates that exceeding the SAR limit constitutes a health and safety non-compliance. The confirmatory version contains more redactions than the initial version.
- 25 April 2024 — CETECOM measurement logs and analyses forwardedDOCUMENT 42 — Partial access
Correspondence forwarding CETECOM measurement logs, an analysis of the handset’s behaviour and ANFR exports. It notes that DASY files require specific tools. Technical annexes 43 and 44 remain withheld.
- 14 May 2024 — French responses forwardedDOCUMENT 46.1 — Partial access
Email of 14 May 2024 forwarding France’s responses to additional questions, with a reminder of the Commission’s request. The redactions mainly concern email headers and identities.
- ANFR responses of 13 May 2024: five pages withheldDOCUMENT 46.3 — Partial access
Annotated version of ANFR’s responses to additional questions, dated 13 May 2024 in the document title. The visible content concerns Protocol 2 and TAS; the answers are heavily redacted and pages 3–7 are withheld.
Apple: technical responses (6)
- 31 October 2022 — Apple’s response on SAR and algorithmsDOCUMENT 4 — Partial access
Apple responds to concerns about power levels, user precautions and SAR. It states that its algorithms are verified separately and refers to UL testing. Entire sections of technical discussion are redacted.
- EU declaration of conformity for models A2403 and A2404DOCUMENT 23 — Partial access
EU declaration of conformity for A2403/A2404: the directives and standards cited, notified body UL, certificate number and date of 28 June 2021. This declaration sets out the manufacturer’s claim of conformity.
- Apple’s presentation to the EU Radio Equipment Directive expert groupDOCUMENT 37 — Full access
Apple’s presentation to the RED expert group: it challenges the French interpretation and addresses Body Detect, motion sensors, proposed protocols, third-party tests and the scope of the software fix. The conformity conclusions presented are Apple’s own.
- 10 October 2023 — Apple’s public statement on French testsDOCUMENT 40.4 — Full access
Copy of Apple’s public statement of 10 October 2023. Apple describes its detection of separation from the body, defends the device’s safety and presents iOS 17.1 as an adaptation to French testing. These statements are attributed to the manufacturer.
- Apple requests a formal consultation with the CommissionDOCUMENT 61.3 — Partial access
Letter from Apple to the Commission, despite the file name “ANFR-iPhone12_Letter to EC”. Apple requests formal consultation under Article 41 of the Radio Equipment Directive, separate from its participation in the EG RE group, and wishes to submit further information.
- March 2025 — Apple raises a device traceability issueDOCUMENT 62.1 — Partial access
Apple–Commission correspondence from March 2025 concerning alleged discrepancies between the serial/IMEI numbers of sampled devices and those in test reports. Apple raises a possible procedural irregularity; the email does not establish that irregularity on its own.
Apple’s legal advisers (5)
- January 2023 — Law firm Signature challenges the formal noticeDOCUMENT 9 — Partial access
Apple’s legal counsel responds to the formal notice, disputes the allegations and requests a technical meeting. The visible passages cite the commercial consequences of withdrawal and tests at 3.90 W/kg. The technical arguments are largely redacted. The portal says 21 January; the letter itself is dated 20 January 2023.
- 7 February 2023 — Power information and test-protocol preparationDOCUMENT 10 — Partial access
Apple’s legal counsel agrees to replace the term “Power Class” with a maximum-power value in dBm, first online and then in printed guides. It announces additional documents on SAR and the test protocol.
- 31 May 2023 — Letter from law firm Signature: eleven pages withheldDOCUMENT 14 — Partial access
Response from law firm Signature to ANFR on 31 May 2023 concerning the protocol and technical documentation. The visible text criticises ANFR’s position and lists annexes. Original pages 4–14 are explicitly withheld.
- 4 October 2023 — Timetable and France-only scope of the software fixDOCUMENT 18 — Partial access
Apple confirms the rollout timetable for firmware 4.06.02 in iOS 17.1 and states that the fix submitted to ANFR is specific to France. It says it will await the outcome of the European procedure for other markets.
- 6 October 2023 — Software fix rollout and consumer informationDOCUMENT 20 — Partial access
Apple’s legal counsel responds on deployment of the software fix, beta stages, consumer information and support. Apple maintains that the iPhone 12 can be used safely without the update; this is Apple’s position, not an independent conclusion.
JRC: scientific findings (1)
- 25 July 2024 — JRC scientific findingsDOCUMENT 64 — Partial access
JRC analysis dated 25 July 2024: the chronology of protocols, non-compliant tests followed by a fix, and a review of CETECOM methods. The JRC identifies gaps in the standard concerning sensors and dynamic algorithms and calls for harmonised test methods to be updated. Several findings are redacted.
European authorities and ICSMS (4)
- 5 October 2023 — ICSMS safeguard notificationDOCUMENT 1 — Partial access
ICSMS safeguard form initiated on 5 October 2023. It describes the French withdrawal, the limb SAR exceedance, testing and exchanges with Apple. It refers to the annexed reports and decisions.
- ICSMS record: compliance and market-surveillance measuresDOCUMENT 2 — Partial access
Thirteen-page ICSMS record covering product identification, document review, health and safety non-compliance, applicable standards and action taken. Blank fields are not, by themselves, evidence of redaction.
- Ireland’s objection to the French measureDOCUMENT 30 — Partial access
ComReg’s objection to the French measure. The Irish authority cites the documentation and results supplied by Apple, states that it did not perform technical tests on the iPhone 12, and requests a joint assessment by the Commission.
- ANFR presentation on SAR testing and the iPhone 12 caseDOCUMENT 38 — Partial access
ANFR presentation: SAR market-surveillance context, applicable limits, the timeline of the iPhone 12 case and the operation of power-reduction mechanisms. The file carries ADCO RED markings from October 2023 despite being classified under EG RE. Some slides are redacted.
European Commission: questions and decisions (5)
- Questions to ANFR on sensors, TAS and test configurationsDOCUMENT 41.2 — Partial access
Bilingual questions from the Commission to ANFR about motion sensors, the use of Protocol 2, TAS and radio configurations. The visible text refers to exceedances in several frequency bands and requests explanations of test parameters.
- Further questions on Protocol 2 and TASDOCUMENT 45.2 — Partial access
Additional questions on the full acceptance of Protocol 2 and TAS not operating on certain frequencies: affected ports, repeatability and activation. Several questions or parts of the context are redacted.
- Questions to Apple on UL/TÜV tests and the software fixDOCUMENT 49.2 — Partial access
Questions to Apple about UL and TÜV tests, differences between ports and bands, motion sensors, TAS and the specific effects of the iOS 17.1 fix. Part of the results table is visible; many questions are redacted.
- 14 May 2024 — Meeting between the Commission and ANFRDOCUMENT 47.2 — Partial access
Minutes of the Commission–ANFR meeting on 14 May 2024 about Protocol 2, CETECOM results and TAS. They also describe interpretations of the Irish objection procedure and next steps. These are internal minutes, not a position formally endorsed by every participant.
- 10 August 2026 — Confirmatory decision on access to documentsDECISION — Full access
Confirmatory decision C(2026)5810 of 10 August 2026: review of commercial-interest refusals, further releases and continued withholding of technical documents. The Commission cites confidentiality, manufacturers’ cooperation and the absence of a demonstrated overriding public interest.
Additional document (1)
- Photograph of the iPhone 12 testedDOCUMENT 26 — Full access
Photograph of the iPhone 12 examined during inspection. The dark screen and casing are part of the photograph, not redactions.
Around 60 additional documents
Our NGO also holds around 60 documents not yet published on the Commission’s portal. They will be made available here with free public access as they are uploaded and versions suitable for publication are checked.




